Coming back for his second season, Mets Manager Carlos Mendoza is looking to follow-up a great rookie managerial season with more wins and success in 2025. His first season as Mets manager resulted in an 89-win season and playoff success reaching the NLCS. While many thought he did enough to win “NL Manager of the Year” he finished 3rd in voting. Will Carlos eventually make the list as one of the top managers in Mets history? Only time will tell. In the meantime here is our list of top Managers in Mets History.

5. Willie Randolph (2005–2008)

• Managed the 2006 team to 97 wins, tied for the second-most in franchise history, and led them to within one game of the World Series.
• Helped usher in a new era of Mets baseball, featuring stars like David Wright, Carlos Beltrán, and José Reyes.

4. Terry Collins (2011–2017)

• Led the Mets to the 2015 National League pennant, their first World Series appearance in 15 years.
• Longest-tenured manager in Mets history (1,134 games), known for his resilience and ability to keep the team competitive.

3. Bobby Valentine (1996–2002)

• Guided the Mets to the 2000 World Series (Subway Series against the Yankees), a major achievement.
• One of the most charismatic and beloved managers in team history, known for his tactical mind and fiery personality.

2. Gil Hodges (1968–1971)

• Led the Miracle Mets to their first-ever World Series championship in 1969, transforming the team from perennial losers into champions.
• Revered by fans and players for his leadership, discipline, and ability to develop young talent.

1. Davey Johnson (1984–1990)

• Managed the Mets to their second-ever World Series title in 1986.
• Holds the franchise record for most wins (595) and highest winning percentage (.588) among long-tenured managers.

Matt

See Full Bio